Quick Fife Lake MI MLS Search

Browse All Fife Lake MI Between $300K - $400K Properties for Sale

$395,000
3 Baths 1946582 MLS Village Of Fife Lake BLDG.
Built in 1886 overlooking Fife Lake, this historic triplex offers lake views, income potential, and the opportunity to create something special. The expansive deck provides year-round views of Fife Lake, a popular Northern Michigan all-sports lake known for boating, fishing, and year-round recreation. It is the kind of setting that keeps visitors coming back season after season and tenants happy with their living arrangements Currently configured as three rental units, the property offers flexibility for investors, seasonal rental operators, or buyers looking to restore a piece of local history. Originally constructed as a mercantile building before evolving into a residence and later a triplex, the property has been adapted to changing needs for nearly 140 years and is ready for the next chapter. With current rental rates below market and all three units offering seasonal rental potential, there are multiple paths to increasing value. Whether your goal is short-term rentals, long-term income, or a thoughtful restoration, the opportunity is clear. At less than $133,000 per unit, opportunities like this are becoming increasingly difficult to find. This is not a turnkey property, but for buyers willing to roll up their sleeves, it offers a remarkable view, easy access to the lake, and the chance to create significant value through vision, patience, and effort. The neighboring property may also be available. Ask for details.

118 E State Street, Fife Lake

$375,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 1946436 MLS N/A BLDG.
Some properties check boxes. This one builds memories. Tucked into 6+ wooded acres bordering State Land in Wexford County, and within Fife Lake - this one-of-a-kind Northern Michigan compound was built for people who live for the outdoors and know how to come home in comfort. Immediate access to ORV, ATV, and snowmobile trails, a private motocross/side-by-side track winding through the property, and some of the best hunting land in the region make this a four-season recreational dream. The main home is warm, well-maintained, and move-in ready. Inside, an open-concept layout connects the living room, anchored by a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, to a generous kitchen with dual skylights, abundant cabinetry, a peninsula, and a dining area with slider access to the covered porch. That porch deserves a mention of its own: deep, covered, and oriented toward the wooded property, it's the kind of space you'll use from May through October. The spacious primary suite offers real room to unwind, with a private en suite bath and views of the trees. Just steps away, the custom barndominium lodge is something else entirely. A full knotty pine kitchen, custom tongue-and-groove plank ceiling, wall-to-wall cabinetry and stone tile backsplash feeds into a sprawling great room with a handcrafted log-post bar, wood stove set in a river rock surround, dining for a crowd, flex sleeping space, and nearly 800 sq ft of covered patio/carport. This isn't a garage conversion, it's a purpose-built gathering place with serious character. Whether you're envisioning a family compound, a four-season sportsman's retreat, or a Northern Michigan getaway with room to breathe and space to play, this property delivers on every count. State Land access. Private trails. Two structures that couldn't be more different and couldn't work together better. See link to virtual tour!

11486 Old US Hwy 131, Fife Lake

$359,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 1943980 MLS Na BLDG.
Escape to your private sanctuary in the wilds of Northern Michigan on Oak Hill Road — a quiet, private road that winds through a magnificent hardwood forest just minutes from Fife Lake. This rare custom-built ranch home, owned by the original owners, sits surrounded by towering hardwoods on a peaceful, secluded property where the only sounds are the whisper of the wind through the trees and the call of the wild. Imagine stepping out your door into a true outdoor paradise: World-class fly fishing on the legendary Manistee River in nearby Old Sharon — some of the best in the Midwest. Miles upon miles of trails right out your back door for hiking, horseback riding, dirt biking, SxS adventures, or snowmobiling. Campfires that burn late into the night under a sky bursting with stars and the glowing Milky Way. Hunting, exploring, and four-wheeling through hundreds of acres of pristine Northern Michigan wilderness. Just a few miles north and west (as the eagle flies) to East Lake or Fife Lake for boating, swimming, and all your favorite water sports including fishing or a little further down the road, Fife Lake The custom home itself offers approximately 2,200+ sq ft of comfortable living space with 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths. Highlights include a dramatic two-way fireplace shared between the dining room and living room, a walk-out basement, and a massive oversized pole barn fully equipped with a hoist, air compressor, and everything you need for projects, toys, or winter storage. A seller favorite is sipping morning coffee on the deck while listening to and watching wildlife. Casting a line for trophy trout, or roaring down snow-covered trails on your sled, this property delivers the ultimate Northern Michigan lifestyle — raw, peaceful, and unforgettable. A true rare find for the outdoor enthusiast who wants to live immersed in nature.

309 Oak Hill Road, Fife Lake

$324,900
4 Beds 2 Baths 1932140 MLS Fife Lake BLDG.
Nestled in the heart of the picturesque Fife Lake community, this lovely new offering is a true gem! Featuring 4 spacious bedrooms on the main floor and 2 beautifully designed bathrooms, this home is perfect for families seeking comfort and style. The fully finished walk-out basement adds an extra layer of living space, ideal for relaxation or entertaining guests. The property boasts an oversized lot, ensuring ample outdoor space for enjoyment. Step out onto the large deck and patio area, perfect for alfresco dining or enjoying serene views of the sparkling waters of Fife Lake. A charming little she-shed adds a touch of whimsy, offering a private spot for hobbies, crafting, or simply unwinding in your own personal sanctuary. The detached 2.5 car garage provides convenient storage, while the home’s prime location ensures you’re never far from the lake or town amenities. Fife Lake is an all-sports lake, offering year-round fun, from boating and fishing in the summer to ice fishing and snowmobiling in the winter. Residents also get to enjoy some of the best fireworks displays in the north! Just a block away, you’ll find public lake access, two parks, and sidewalks for leisurely strolls through town. For nature lovers, Blue Lake, Mirror Lake, and five access points to the Manistee River are all within a 5-mile radius. This is truly a prime location for those who enjoy the best of both lakeside living and outdoor adventure. Come experience the beauty and tranquility of Fife Lake! Home sale also includes a 1-Year Home Warranty!

417 E State, Fife Lake

$389,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 1925419 MLS Metes And Bounds BLDG.
Amazing and meticulously maintained custom built home on 19.3 acres of hardwoods, evergreens and open ground. Such a private but convenient location with frontage on two roads, within 1/4 mile of the Garfield township hall and fire department, township park and disc golf course. Great location to travel from and explore places such as Kalkaska, South Boardman, Fife Lake and nearby access to the Manistee River. The home and property are great for all, whether its one's primary home or their secondary Northern Michigan retreat. The home has so many peaceful areas and spectacular views throughout, you will never run out of areas for peace and tranquility. This home and its setting make it easy to appreciate all of the four seasons of Northern Michigan's beauty. During the spring and summer enjoy the beautifully landscaped fenced yard and meandering trails where you can watch the birds, deer and other wildlife. If the weather changes or its time to entertain friends and family you will be sure to enjoy the enclosed porch addition with its beautiful high beams, windows and ceiling fan. On those crisp fall evenings after enjoying the beautiful fall colors, or a long day's hunt it's time to pick your favorite room to warm up in, whether it is upstairs with its fireplace, or in the partially finished downstairs with its pellet and woodstove, you will most definitely be comforted! This property consists of many outbuildings for your toys or a place for that handy person to work on projects. The insulated 26x35 outbuilding has 220 electric and a pit for your vehicle repairs. If this is not enough storage, there is a 34x36 farm barn with electric, a 12x24 car port and several other garden sheds throughout the property. The home also features a surveillance camera system and 6kw solar system for added benefits in its rural area. The never-ending list of qualities and features, makes this a must see in person property to fully appreciate all that this one has to offer!

915 W Sharon Road, SE, Fife Lake

$310,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 1924217 MLS Rural BLDG.
Discover the perfect blend of rustic charm and serene country living with this enchanting 1920s farmhouse nestled on 40 acres in the tranquil setting of Fife Lake, MI. Located at 8300 SE Campbell Rd, this property offers a peaceful retreat with the convenience of nearby amenities. Step inside to find 1,340 square feet of living space, featuring four cozy bedrooms and one & a half baths. The home retains its vintage charm, awaiting your personal touch. The upstairs area, spanning 720 square feet, is mostly gutted and presents a blank canvas ready for your creative vision. Additionally, there is an unfinished basement providing ample storage space. Being sold AS-IS The original fieldstone-covered porch welcomes you to this charming farmhouse. The yard is partially shaded, offering a cool retreat during warmer months. The property is predominantly wooded, with trails winding through the picturesque landscape, perfect for nature enthusiasts. A spacious 36x46 barn with a lean-to, an additional pole barn, and multiple other outbuildings provide ample storage and project space for all your needs. Situated in a quiet, country setting, this property is just a few miles from the beautiful Manistee River and surrounded by abundant state-owned land, making it a haven for outdoor enthusiasts. The area is renowned for its excellent hunting opportunities, adding to the appeal for nature lovers and sportsmen alike. Embrace the potential of this character-filled farmhouse and create your dream country home. Schedule a viewing today to experience the tranquility and charm of this unique property in Fife Lake, MI.

8300 SE Campbell, Fife Lake

$361,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 1914199 MLS
The setting is 20 acres on a dirt road off the beaten path! Gorgeous hardwoods, red pines on the road shelter this home from any road view, it's very private. The red pine will provide a possible future income to the new owner. The home is a beautiful 2 story with a walkout basement. (2) 47 ft long covered porches on the front and back! Seller just installed to new concrete pads for the walk out basement and the back porch. The home has a very warm feeling with all of the tongue and groove knotty pine, cathedral ceilings, log beamed, and beautiful custom built handrail to the upstairs. Custom built cabinets and nice large center island in the kitchen. Plenty of room to cook those amazing gourmet meals and plenty of space to store all of your kitchen gadgets. The main floor has a full bath and 2 bedrooms. The Master suit is the upstairs 31 x 13'5" log beamed, hardwood floors, 2 ceiling fans, plenty of windows for natural light, the suite bath has a garden tub, shower, walk in closet and 2 windows for natural light. The basement is set up to be a possible apt or finish the 2 rooms with egress windows as bedrooms. There is a large family room with walk out sliding door. A full bath that needs to be hooked up to plumbing but everything is in place just needs to be finished. There is also a 23 x 13' room in the basement that is plumbed for a kitchen. The laundry room is in the basement. The 30 x 40 pole barn has electricity, a concrete floor, tall sliding doors and a utility door. There is also a shop that the seller lived in while building the house it is heated with the out door wood stove and or propane. This building is plumbed still but the seller has removed the fixtures. A 24 x 30 equine barn with a loft to store hay front door on the upper story for a hay conveyer. Electricity, concrete floors, 2 stalls, and a cleared area for pasture. There is also a 12x8 chicken coop, and another 14 x 16 animal barn. The wood shed by the wood burner is 16 x 19. Sold as is.

9498 SE Shively Road, Fife Lake

Start Your Search

Between $300K - $400K Fife Lake Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $300k - $400k properties available in Fife Lake and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!