Quick Lake Leelanau MI MLS Search

Browse All Lake Leelanau MI Historical Properties for Sale

6261 E Baxter Drive, Lake Leelanau
$995,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1951914 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.
Experience the timeless charm of Northern Michigan lakefront living with this inviting home offering 96 feet of private frontage on beautiful North Lake Leelanau. Tucked away at the end of a private road, this property is nestled on a wooded .64-acre parcel with a sandy lake bottom and private dock, providing an idyllic setting for swimming, boating, and making lasting summer memories. Originally built in 1958, the house is filled with warmth and character, featuring natural wood finishes, exposed rafters, vaulted wood ceilings, and a cozy wood-burning fireplace. The distinctive ceiling design was thoughtfully incorporated into the original construction to showcase the beauty of the woodwork, creating an inviting atmosphere reminiscent of classic Northern Michigan cottages. Original Douglas fir flooring remains in the living room (beneath carpeting) and the two original bedrooms. An addition in the mid-1980s expanded the home to include a spacious primary bedroom, bathroom, and expanded kitchen. Large windows and glass doors bring in natural light and offer beautiful views of the lake and surrounding landscape. Step outside to the spacious lakeside deck, perfect for outdoor dining, soaking up the sunshine, or simply enjoying the lazy days of summer. Additional conveniences include central air conditioning, natural gas heat, and a detached two-car garage. With three bedrooms and an appealing blend of original character and thoughtful additions, this North Lake Leelanau retreat offers the opportunity to enjoy the simple pleasures of waterfront living for generations to come. Please note: E Baxter Drive is a private dead-end road and does not provide through access to the adjacent E Ryans Way.

6261 E Baxter Drive, Lake Leelanau

3387 N Lake Leelanau, Lake Leelanau
$3,650,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1947913 MLS ⋅ Terrace Place, Metes And Bound BLDG.
Presenting a one of a kind East Leland residence. With over 160' of sandy shoreline on North Lake Leelanau, this offering features expansive westerly views sweeping from the beautiful waters of the north end, over the village of Leland, to the iconic profile of Whaleback. This special year-round home has been enjoyed by one family, throughout several generations. What began as a simple, early 1960s cottage, has grown into a contemporary gem, rich with quality finishes, and designed to meet the expectations of luxury on the lake in Northern Michigan. In 2016, this home was comprehensively remodeled and expanded - absolutely transforming the original lake-side cottage, while preserving special historical elements as nostalgic reminders of the past. Vintage slate floors, black cherry paneling from North Manitou Island, Pecky cypress, and redwood beams remain as decorative features, and an outstanding hand-split, fieldstone fireplace visually anchors the main entertaining space. Built to accommodate the extended family, the main house is complimented by an attached studio / flex space with private entry. In the main house, all rooms are oriented lakeside to showcase views of the water. Lake-level, a fabulous primary suite, kitchen, living room, and library all walk-out to a beautiful outdoor patio. On the main floor, a generous family room with covered deck and 3 bedrooms stretch along the front of the home, with every window capturing sunset views. Situated privately on the third floor above the 3-car garage, the studio (or Bird's Nest) has peekaboo views of the lake and yard. This independent suite is a carefully curated bonus space with amenities for guests to enjoy and space for kids to play. Numerous noteworthy features have been incorporated into this home. Every aspect of this modern, lakeside retreat reflects a thoughtful, generational investment into the architecture; perfectly echoing and enhancing this special piece of shoreline!

3387 N Lake Leelanau, Lake Leelanau

968 S Manitou Trail, Lake Leelanau
$3,500,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1947207 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.
Legacy lakefront with 150 feet of private waterfront on beautiful Good Harbor Bay, this 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of waterfront living and a prime Leelanau County location. Inside, hardwood floors flow throughout the main level, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The kitchen features custom cabinets, granite countertops and ample space for gathering with family and friends. Three fireplaces provide comfort and ambiance throughout the home, while expansive windows frame picturesque views of Good Harbor Bay. The spacious primary suite includes a private balcony overlooking the water, providing a peaceful retreat to start and end each day. The home features a large office with it's own private entrance from north side of the house, this room could also be ideal for a theater room. The walkout basement opens directly to the patio, offering easy access and convenient storage for beach equipment and outdoor furniture. Nestled between Pyramid Point in the Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore, the pristine waters surrounding Whaleback and the Manitou Islands, and the historic Crib, this exceptional setting offers some of the most breathtaking scenery in Northern Michigan. Watch freighters navigate the Manitou Passage, fishing tugs make their daily runs, and bald eagles soar overhead. Every season brings its own beauty, from dramatic winter ice formations to unforgettable sunsets that paint a different masterpiece each evening. Nearly 1,900 square feet of decking provides the perfect space for entertaining or simply relaxing while taking in the panoramic views, all surrounded by mature, beautifully landscaped grounds. Situated just 4.5 miles south of Leland and 14 miles north of Glen Arbor. The original cottage was built in 1941 and the addition was build in 1996 along with the cottage being remodeled. The home is effecient for heating and electric, previous year utility costs available.

968 S Manitou Trail, Lake Leelanau

202 S Saint Joseph, Lake Leelanau
$1,400,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1946950 MLS ⋅ Na BLDG.
JUST REDUCED! - Hotel Northern was established in 1903 by Frank Hahnenberg - a Leelanau local who had returned from adventures on the west coast. Here, on the corner of the main intersection in town, Hahnenberg built his grand hotel from local lumber and stone, and in doing so, created one of the most recognizable buildings in the village. More than a century later, this iconic Colonial structure still stands proudly, thanks to the restoration efforts of the current owners who have lovingly cared for and improved this fabulous property over the last 20 years. This special offering includes 3 platted lots, all commercially zoned. The original hotel, now a residence, and detached guest house, a successful rental, sit on 2 lots, while a single vacant parcel remains adjacent, to the west. Structurally, this vintage home has been made sound. Architecturally, it is a masterclass in craftsmanship, quality, and style, seamlessly blending historical elements with inspiring modern highlights. Beautiful original hardwood floors quietly echo a century of living, and are in good company amongst other heirloom elements such as a cast-iron tub, vintage wallpaper, and a Victorian mantle. Newer features compliment these historical pieces - including floor to ceiling built-in bookshelves with minimalist trim and detailing, rough-sawn wooden beams which open the plan, and energy efficient elements such as new windows and solar panels. Whenever possible, reclaimed or recycled natural materials have been incorporated into this home. This sensibility and attention to the environment carries through to the landscaping which features wild native plants corralled by custom stone walls and walkways, a trellised path to a sundrenched lawn, and a private patio overlooking a water garden of koi and flowering lily pads. This exceptional listing offers exciting versatility. Whether a dream residence or Lake Leelanau’s next hot commercial destination, this property is ready for the next chapter!

202 S Saint Joseph, Lake Leelanau

553 S Lake Shore Drive, Lake Leelanau
$1,750,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1946402 MLS ⋅ Narrows BLDG.
Nestled along 100 feet of private frontage on beautiful Lake Leelanau, this exceptional waterfront property captures everything people love about life in Leelanau County. Set on a spacious lot with a sweeping lawn stretching to the water's edge, the setting invites long summer days on the lake, evening bonfires by the shore, and unforgettable gatherings with family and friends. The thoughtfully maintained 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home is designed to make the most of its waterfront setting, with lake views from many of the home's primary living spaces. The main residence features three spacious bedrooms, two full baths, and a convenient powder room. A large finished guest space adjacent to the garage provides additional seasonal accommodations for visitors. The updated kitchen offers generous workspace and opens comfortably to the living and dining areas, while expansive windows frame picturesque views of Lake Leelanau. Recent improvements include a newer septic system and drain field, providing peace of mind for years to come. With over 8,500 acres of water and more than 40 miles of shoreline, Lake Leelanau is one of Northern Michigan's most treasured destinations for boating, fishing, swimming, and waterfront recreation. From this central location, you'll enjoy easy access to award-winning wineries, renowned restaurants, golf courses, and the charming towns that make Leelanau County such a special place to call home. Whether you're looking for a year-round residence or a seasonal retreat, this is a rare opportunity to own 100 feet of private frontage on one of Northern Michigan's most beloved lakes.

553 S Lake Shore Drive, Lake Leelanau

3630 S Stanley Street, Lake Leelanau
$1,200,000
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1932591 MLS ⋅ Plat Of Stanley BLDG.
This property presents an incredible opportunity to own 200 feet of desirable waterfront on the stunning sunset side of South Lake Leelanau. Nestled in beautiful Leelanau County, this expansive 2.22-acre parcel offers tranquil seclusion, with the house situated close to the water, ideal for enjoying breathtaking evening sunsets and convenient access to the lake. The residence features a 3-bedroom ranch layout with an open concept living area and kitchen, both oriented towards the picturesque views of the water. A covered patio extends from the living room, making it a perfect venue for entertaining guests or unwinding while soaking in the scenery. Additionally, the 32x48 pole barn, equipped with a cement floor and electrical service, is perfect for storing boats, jet skis, and more. With endless possibilities for enhancement, this property boasts natural surroundings (Eagles nest and Otters) and a lifestyle centered around waterfront living. Its prime location allows for easy boating excursions into Lake Leelanau and Leland, where you can enjoy dining and shopping. Notably, 100 feet of the waterfront is protected by a conservation easement, resulting in reduced taxes for the owner and ensuring that no further construction will disrupt this serene environment. An additional detached garage with overhead doors and a 24x15 heated/insulated area perfect for a "Man Cave"! Overall, this property is a remarkable opportunity to embrace a delightful lakeside lifestyle!

3630 S Stanley Street, Lake Leelanau

2801 N Lake Leelanau Drive, Lake Leelanau
$1,810,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1925839 MLS ⋅ Metes And Bounds BLDG.
The moment you set foot on the land surrounding vintage Mossy Bank cottage, you will feel the magic that exists here on North Lake Leelanau. Transported back in time to the days of original owner, Michigan cartographer John Nellist, you can just imagine someone like Ernest Hemingway writing in a chair near the old stone fireplace. Remodeled and expanded in 1974 (by the second and current owner) with the ultimate in beauty and functionality by renowned Suttons Bay architect Roger Hummel, the current cottage is anything but cookie-cutter yet features the hallmarks of Hummel's craft throughout including the white stucco interior and exterior, the rough sawn hardwood floors and peeled cedar rafters, and the peg ladder up to the kids' sleeping loft. The original living room still contains many elements from Nellist's construction - the '1921' carved into one of the beams above the fireplace, the windows from an old school house, the fireplace swing arm from an old log cabin, the fireplace hood made from an old copper boiler, and the native hemlock floors coated with boiling linseed oil. The family room features with a cushioned window bench, built-in side tables and storage shelves/cabinets, and a giant middle table ideal for crafts, projects, and family meals. Not one detail is overlooked in the foyer, with a sliding galvanized tin boot tray, a wall for hanging items with movable pegs, and a wall of storage cabinets designed to blend into the tongue-and-groove interior (you'll find the same cabinets in the laundry room). Thoughtfully placed skylights and windows throughout fill the space with generous natural light and create architectural interest. The boiler was upgraded to a state-of-the-art system in 2023 with an on-demand water heater. The 126' of waterfront is a rippled hard-sand bottom - ideal for swimming and boating, and it's west-facing frontage hosts breathtaking sunsets. So many memories have been created here - it's time for your memories to begin.

2801 N Lake Leelanau Drive, Lake Leelanau

6680 E Alpers Road, Lake Leelanau
$1,738,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1924605 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.
Private sanctuary provides the best of both worlds – water and woods. The 1.85-acre corner parcel set along a private road and CR 641 includes an expansive 225 ft of frontage on North Lake Leelanau. The classic two-story Arts and Crafts house has a story-book presence with a covered porch, shed dormer, brick chimney and cedar shake siding. Inside you'll enjoy the advantage of large west-facing windows that provide a flood of natural light through the filter of its wooded setting, as well as views of dramatic evening sunsets. Wood flooring adorns the entire main living area that includes a spacious living room with wood fireplace, large dining area and updated kitchen with a butcher block workstation. The house has a full bathroom on the main level, 3 bedrooms upstairs plus an office/loft, a shared bathroom with private shower and toilet, and an additional large room ideal for a sleeper sofa. The substantial entry room is lined with closets and cabinets providing storage uncommon in vintage lake houses. A walking path of pavers leads to a detached garage with an upstairs en suite studio/4th bedroom with built-in shelving, sink, mini fridge, and private shower and toilet. This ample 625 sq. ft. space could easily convert to a bunk room for up to 6 people. Just a short walk across the street and through a stand of privacy trees lies your waterfront oasis with a deck, lakeside sauna and outdoor stone dining table. Don’t miss this opportunity for a private lakeside retreat.

6680 E Alpers Road, Lake Leelanau

6125 E Ryans Way, Lake Leelanau
$2,890,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 1921859 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.
A magnificent creation, where "Up North Cottage & Craftsman Estate" blend beautifully. If you are looking to begin, or continue your "Leelanau Legacy", look no further. This beauty rests upon approximately 120' of prime, sandy/firm lake bottom on North Lake Leelanau. Located on the south shore in a slight cove that is protected from the prevailing summer winds and late-day glare of the sun. Over 4000 s.f. of absolute fun & functional living spaces (not including the awesome bonus room with 1/2 bath above garage). A beautifully updated (2016) kitchen facing the lake with granite tops, new appliances. The dining room & 4-season sun/family room have beautifully re-finished hardwood floors. On the other side of kitchen, there are gorgeous exposed timbers over the spacious yet cozy living room with fieldstone wood-burning f.p. There is a second fieldstone f.p. with natural gas in the dining room. A total of three master bedrooms each with en-suite bathrooms. The 4th bd room is on the main floor with walk-in closet. A large open loft area upstairs perfect for many uses. Wait till you see the (added in 2007) custom lakeside outdoor kitchen with seating for 6, classic outdoor shower, a unique "cut" for walk-right-in sandy lake entrance. Too much to mention, this property must be seen in-person to appreciate. New driveway June 2024. Lots of FLEX space for accommodations. All measurements, zoning & other listing data have been obtained via seller and third party sources, deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Buyer should verify prior to closing. Check out all attachments for helpful information. Home has a whole house carbon water filter system (NuVoH2O) in main water line. DaVinci Roofscapes polymer roof new in 2017 with transferable lifetime warranty.

6125 E Ryans Way, Lake Leelanau

Start Your Search

Lake Leelanau Historical Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Lake Leelanau and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!