Suttons Bay MI 2+ Acres Real Estate, Homes for Sale

6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1948315 MLS ⋅ Bayscape Hills BLDG.

Perched above West Grand Traverse Bay with sweeping water views and unforgettable sunsets, this fully furnished Leelanau retreat offers the Northern Michigan lifestyle buyers dream about. Situated on 2.5 private acres within the gated community of Bayscape Hills at Guinan Farms, this exceptional 6-bedroom, 3-bath home combines privacy, luxury, and convenience just minutes from downtown Suttons Bay. Walls of windows capture stunning bay views throughout the home, filling the spacious interior with natural light and creating the perfect setting for gathering family and friends. Whether hosting summer guests, enjoying wine country weekends, or creating memories for generations to come, this home was designed for the way Northern Michigan is meant to be enjoyed. The walkout lower level offers additional flexibility with unfinished space ready for a future sauna, while the attached 3-car garage includes an EV charging outlet for modern convenience. Located minutes from award-winning wineries, beaches, golf, dining, and the charm of downtown Suttons Bay, this turnkey property offers the rare opportunity to close and immediately begin enjoying everything Leelanau County has to offer.

1476 Brencris Lane, Suttons Bay

$1,100,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1948284 MLS ⋅ Metes And Bounds BLDG.

Experience refined Leelanau County living in this masterfully reimagined estate set on 3 park-like acres with 182 feet of shared sandy West Bay frontage on Stony Point Peninsula. The spacious main level features 10-foot ceilings, rich wood flooring, and an inviting living room centered around a striking gas fireplace. The exquisitely renovated kitchen is appointed with Wolverine Cabinetry, a cabinet-paneled Sub-Zero refrigerator, premium Bosch appliances, quartz countertops and matching backsplash, and a sunny breakfast nook. The adjoining dining area opens to the covered rear deck, where a premium Sundance hot tub overlooks the private grounds. The main level primary suite offers a walk-in closet and a stylishly updated ensuite bath. The walkout lower level expands the living space with a generous recreation room, versatile flex space, an additional bedroom with a shared bath, and direct access to the spacious patio. Surrounded by exceptional privacy, the property also includes a second buildable parcel. All of this is just minutes from Suttons Bay and a short drive to downtown Traverse City.

12175 E Old Orchard Trail, Suttons Bay

$825,000

1947919 MLS ⋅ Metes And Bounds BLDG.

Set in the rolling countryside of the storied Leelanau Peninsula, this 76.33-acre homestead is waiting for you to personalize it to your needs. The land is mix of level and rolling topography with wooded and open sections. In addition to the home there is also a barn and numerous other smaller outbuildings. This would make a great hobby farm, hunting retreat, or private estate. The land is adjacent near the road to the Leelanau Trail which connects to the TART Trail, giving you the ability to cycle/walk/run from north of the Suttons Bay, south through Traverse City and east to M-72/Bates Rd. in Williamsburg.

4626 S Center Highway, Suttons Bay

$825,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1947914 MLS ⋅ Metes And Bounds BLDG.

Set in the rolling countryside of the storied Leelanau Peninsula, this 76.33-acre homestead is waiting for you to personalize it to your needs. The land is mix of level and rolling topography with wooded and open sections. In addition to the home there is also a barn and numerous other smaller outbuildings. This would make a great hobby farm, hunting retreat, or private estate. The land is adjacent near the road to the Leelanau Trail which connects to the TART Trail, giving you the ability to cycle/walk/run from north of the Suttons Bay, south through Traverse City and east to M-72/Bates Rd. in Williamsburg.

4626 S Center Highway, Suttons Bay

$2,620,000

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1947248 MLS ⋅ Metes & Bounds BLDG.

Set on an oversized parcel with an extraordinary 460 feet of private sandy shoreline, this exceptional waterfront property offers a rare opportunity along the coveted shores of Suttons Bay. Enjoy breathtaking sunsets over the water while surrounded by privacy, natural beauty, mature trees, and endless possibilities. Whether you choose to enhance and enjoy the charming cottage-style home or create a legacy estate, the expansive setting provides ample space to bring your vision to life. Potential land division opportunities may exist; buyers should conduct their own due diligence and verification. Conveniently located just 2 miles from the vibrant village of Suttons Bay, the property offers easy access to boutique shopping, dining, and everyday conveniences. Traverse City is only 15 miles away, Cherry Capital Airport is within 20 miles, and historic Fishtown in Leland is just 12 miles from your doorstep. Surrounded by the acclaimed wineries, beaches, trails, and year-round outdoor recreation of Leelanau County, this is a truly rare offering in one of Northern Michigan's most sought-after destinations.

737 S Stony Point Road, Suttons Bay

$2,300,000

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1947089 MLS ⋅ Willow Vineyards BLDG.

One of a kind property with the most incredible views over West Grand Traverse Bay offering many possibilities. Currently the home to Willow Winery & Vineyard, this well-established, turn-key property includes a French Provencal villa designed to capture the up close water and vineyard views features classic board-and-batten siding, a cedar shake roof, fireplace and imported cathedral doors from France that open into the primary suite. 11.45 acre site makes it the most approachable & manageable vineyard for the novice wine maker, the experienced or for existing wineries to add this magnificent site to their assets with a tasting room and residence. The impressive stone landscaping has a timeless, century-old character that blends perfectly into the rolling vineyard backdrop. The lower level of the villa is fully outfitted for winery production. A separate winery tasting room, built in the same architectural style, includes a indoor and outdoor guest seating, a bar area, retail space, 1/2 bath and storage above. A two-level equipment barn offers ample space for storage. Currently, the villa operates as a successful short term rental, providing an additional revenue stream. Options to use as a private residence, continued short-term rental or full-time winery operation, Willow offers flexibility, history and unmatched charm in the heart of Leelanau Wine Country. Shown by appointment only.

10702 E Hilltop Road, Suttons Bay

$2,300,000

1947088 MLS ⋅ Willow Vineyard & Winery BLDG.

Discover Willow Winery & Vineyard – the 5th oldest working vineyard & winery on the Leelanau Peninsula boasting incredible views over West Grand Traverse Bay. This well-established, turn-key business/property includes a main home, tasting room, & equipment barn on 11.45 acres. The winery tasting room (seats 25) has retail space, 1/2 bath and storage above. The patio (seats 46). The French Provencal residence is offered turn-key as well with 2 bedrooms, 2 1/2 baths & situated to enjoy the great views of the water & vineyard. Classic board-and-batten siding, a cedar shake roof, wood fireplace and imported cathedral doors from France that open into the primary suite. Impressive stone landscaping has a timeless, century-old character that blends perfectly into the rolling vineyard backdrop. The lower level of the residence is fully outfitted for winery production. The two-level equipment barn offers ample space for storage. The size of this estate makes it very approachable and manageable for the beginner or seasoned wine maker. The home operates as a successful short-term rental, providing an additional revenue stream. Whether as a private residence, continued short-term rental or full-time winery operation, Willow offers flexibility, history and unmatched charm in the heart of Leelanau Wine Country. Bonus, shared frontage on West Bay (1/4 share).

10702 E Hilltop Road, Suttons Bay

$1,645,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1947003 MLS ⋅ Bayside BLDG.

Perched on over two private acres just north of Sutton's Bay and only 20 minutes from downtown Traverse City, this exceptional custom designed residence captures some of the most breathtaking panoramic views of West Grand Traverse Bay. Thoughtfully positioned on one of the premier homesites in the development, the home was architecturally designed to showcase sparkling blue water vistas from nearly every room. Offering more than 3,000 square feet of refined living space, this four bedroom, three bath home seamlessly blends sophisticated design with Northern Michigan luxury. Expansive windows flood the open concept interior with natural light while framing the ever changing bay views. At the heart of the home, the chef's kitchen features a generous island, abundant workspace, and effortless flow into the spacious dining and living areas, creating the perfect setting for entertaining or quiet evenings overlooking the water. The main level is completed by two spacious guest bedrooms, a beautifully appointed full bath, and a convenient laundry room. The upper level is dedicated to a private primary retreat where breathtaking sunrise views greet you each morning. Enjoy direct access to a covered deck, a luxurious spa inspired bath with custom tile shower, an oversized walk in closet, and a private office designed for both productivity and relaxation. The finished walkout lower level offers additional space for gathering and recreation with a welcoming family room overlooking the bay, a fourth bedroom, full bath, dedicated exercise room, creative art studio, and generous storage. Designed for year round enjoyment, the exterior features full length covered decks, an attached three car garage, beautifully landscaped grounds, and a private hot tub perfectly positioned to take in the peaceful surroundings and stunning Northern Michigan scenery. A rare opportunity to experience architectural elegance, exceptional craftsmanship, and unforgettable bay views.

10112 E John Michael Drive, Suttons Bay

$795,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1946363 MLS ⋅ Metes And Bounds BLDG.

A rare Leelanau Township retreat with acreage, water, privacy, guest space, and future-use potential. Set on 17 acres between Suttons Bay, Omena, and Northport, this move-in-ready property includes a 2-bedroom main home with 2 full baths, flexible additional sleeping/living space, extensive decking, and an eclectic retreat feel. The detached garage includes a legally recognized 1-bedroom accessory dwelling with kitchen/living area, 3/4 bath, separate propane wall furnace, year-round usability, and two separate entrances, creating valuable space for guests, extended stays, multi-generational use, or future rental flexibility. The land offers a strong mix of open meadow and mature woods, with the property line following Belanger Creek, a year-round fast-flowing trout stream reached by a short walk through the wooded portion of the property. Access is by newly replaced year-round gravel driveway across adjacent protected acreage, creating an additional privacy buffer before reaching the homesite. Agricultural zoning/use allows horses and outbuildings, giving a future owner room to create hobby-farm or rural-lifestyle infrastructure if desired. A separate unfinished sauna building adds strong amenity potential, and a former boiler building provides additional storage/future-use flexibility. Functioning solar, underground electric service, propane hot-water heat, and a functional wood cook stove/wood-heat option support the retreat setting; an existing wind system is present for a future owner to evaluate. Point Broadband fiber optic service is available for installation; buyer to verify timing, costs, and service terms. A replacement septic permit has been issued; installation will be buyer responsibility. Seller is pursuing a short-term rental permit. STR use remains subject to Leelanau Township approval, completed septic installation, licensing, and all applicable requirements.

10953 E Pobuda Road, Suttons Bay

$300,000

1946069 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.

This gently sloping 10-acre parcel has panoramic views of rolling hills and orchards. Centrally located in Leelanau County—just four miles to Suttons Bay and Lake Leelanau, and under 10 miles to Leland—this location on Maple Valley Road gives you so many options for shopping or dining. This property is the perfect size for your “gentleman’s estate.” No deed restrictions. Bring your mini donkeys!

00 Maple Valley Road, Suttons Bay

$95,000

1946048 MLS ⋅ Bayscape Hills At Guinan Farms BLDG.

Rare opportunity to build in desirable Bayscape Hills. This beautiful 2.2-acre homesite offers a peaceful setting with a small glimpse of Grand Traverse Bay paired with sweeping west-facing orchard and countryside views that capture Leelanau County’s unforgettable sunsets. Surrounded by quality homes and rolling open space, the parcel offers an ideal setting for a custom residence designed to embrace the natural beauty of Northern Michigan. Underground utilities are available, with well and septic to be installed. Conveniently located just minutes from downtown Suttons Bay, dining, wineries, golf, boating, and endless recreation.

Lot 4 E John Michael Drive, Suttons Bay

$648,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1945994 MLS

Well maintained home on 3.67 spectacular private, quiet and serene acres in Leelanau county. This home overlooks beautifully rolling land filled with hardwoods, wildlife and Trillium! This main floor living home features cherry & oak wood flooring, updated kitchen & appliances, quartz countertops, beautiful updated bathrooms with tile showers, composite decking on both rear deck and front covered porch, under deck drainage system, gas fireplace, wood stove, 18’ x 20’ storage pole barn, 16’ x10’ two story garden shed with electricity, green house, metal roof, spiral staircase and a huge master bedroom with a gas fireplace and floor to ceiling Pella windows! Lower level is great for visiting family and overnight guest. Located just a short drive to Suttons Bay, Traverse City, Lake Leelanau, Veronica Valley Park and the Lake Leelanau boat launch.

2160 S Maple Valley Road, Suttons Bay

$899,900

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1945736 MLS ⋅ Woodside Hills BLDG.

BEST BUY IN LEELANAU COUNTY! Custom designed and built showplace in popular Woodside Hills. Super location between TC and Suttons Bay in the heart of wine country. This is a peaceful setting on a 2 acre wooded lot. Many extras and updates since it was originally built for the Parade of Homes. Plenty of natural light showcase the Maple floors with Cherry columns and accents. Numerous updates such as roof, furnace and more. Insulated and finished garage, sound insulated baths...so much more...and priced well below 2025 appraisal! Seller is a licensed real estate salesperson in the State of Michigan.

6261 S Westwood Pkwy, Suttons Bay

$1,300,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1945667 MLS ⋅ Metes And Bounds BLDG.

47 Rolling Acres in Leelanau County — Your Private Park Awaits. Set on 47 gorgeous acres just outside Suttons Bay, this updated one-level home offers the rare combination of privacy, natural beauty, and usable land. The property features a stunning blend of hardwoods, planted pines, and open ground—perfect for wandering, wildlife watching, or creating your own trails. Horses are allowed per zoning. Enjoy quiet afternoons or summer barbeques on the private patio. Inside, the home features a private primary bath with a tile shower, original wood floors, a fireplace, main-floor laundry, and a spacious dining area. The full basement includes finished space and abundant storage. A 30x60 heated pole building with concrete floors, three overhead doors, a sliding door, and plumbing provides exceptional workspace or storage for equipment, hobbies, or vehicles. Move-in ready and beautifully maintained. Owner will consider selling the west 20 acres separately. Floor plan available in camera roll.

1551 N Macksey Road, Suttons Bay

$1,175,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1944783 MLS

Set amidst rolling countryside, this one of a kind homestead offers something special…a place where the land, the setting, and the home all come together, with every detail already brought into the present. The farmhouse has been completely remodeled, blending modern comfort with timeless character. Inside, Coretec flooring flows throughout. The kitchen offers a warm and inviting focal point, featuring a farmhouse sink, convenient pantry, and finishes that feel functional and fitting. Each level of the home includes its own bathroom, both beautifully tiled, with the upstairs bath offering a classic soaking tub perfect for unwinding, along with heated floors that add comfort and quiet luxury. Even the Michigan basement has been meticulously cared for, reflecting the attention given to every corner of the home. Major exterior updates include Tyvek wrap, aluminum siding, gutters with Gutter Helmet, a new septic system in 2023, and a whole house Generac generator, providing peace of mind year round. Step outside and the story truly unfolds. Sweeping countryside vistas offer a daily backdrop that shifts with the seasons. A thoughtfully placed firepit overlooks a valley of fruit trees, creating the perfect setting for evenings under the stars. A 48x30 two-story barn with lean-to and a rustic outbuilding, both with electricity, stand as part of the property’s working farmstead history. Whether you envision bringing the land back into farming, or creating a studio space, workshop, or private retreat, the possibilities here are wide open. While the home has been completely refreshed, the soul of the property still holds that feeling of stepping back in time. Suttons Bay is just minutes away with its shops, eateries, Lake Michigan beaches, and TART Trail for biking and outdoor adventures. Traverse City is an easy 20 minute drive. This is more than a home. It is an opportunity to start writing a new chapter, and it’s ready to welcome you home.

2768 S Center Highway, Suttons Bay

$335,000

1944557 MLS ⋅ Metes & Bounds BLDG.

Exceptionally rare large-acreage parcel within the Village of Suttons Bay, backing directly to 20 acres of Village-owned parkland. One of only a handful of remaining Village properties of this size, this 11.31-acre wooded setting features a variety of building sites and rolling terrain that rises to a scenic elevated ridgeline with seasonal water views. No deed restrictions! Create your own private trail system and connect seamlessly to Bahle Park—offering year-round recreation with direct access to the Village through Bahle Park by foot, snowshoes, or even skis, right from your backyard. Wildlife is abundant, and a small creek meanders along the western boundary, enhancing the natural setting. A rare opportunity to secure a true legacy property with exceptional privacy, all less than 1 mile from downtown Suttons Bay!

E Smiseth Road, Suttons Bay

$265,000

1944175 MLS ⋅ The Points BLDG.

WATER VIEWS! A rare opportunity to own 2.8 acres in "The Points at Suttons Bay", where open space and elevated positioning combine to showcase beautiful views of Grand Traverse Bay and the countryside. The size of this parcel allows for a truly custom build—whether you envision a modern retreat or a timeless Northern Michigan home—with room to create privacy while still being part of a well-established neighborhood. Minutes to Suttons Bay, yet offering a peaceful, tucked-away feel. Sellers have recently combined parcels 3 & 4 to create this spectacular Estate Size parcel. New survey shows the combined parcels and a substantial foot-print for a proposed and approved home plan. See all associated documents. All listing data has been obtained from seller or third party sources and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Buyer, or its agent should verify all for accuracy. Tax ID's 011-600-003-00 & 004-00.

E Spinnaker Lane, Suttons Bay

$1,100,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1944057 MLS ⋅ Metes & Bounds BLDG.

Picturesque contemporary 3 bed 2 1/2 bath home perfectly positioned on over 6 1/2 tree lined acres with stellar views of both Suttons and West Bay. Quaint front porch w/ Grapevine covered breezeway overlooks orchards in all directions. Expansive modern farmhouse kitchen offers an abundance of counter space and cabinets. Custom built-in Banquette is perfect for conversations & coffee. Wood-burning fireplace completes this cozy spot in the perfect kitchen. The open and airy dining room features built-ins, and spectacular views-truly an ideal gathering space. The stylish living room is flooded with natural light &, unique architectural details like full wall customized built-ins, vaulted ceiling & floating fireplace hearth. The expansive picture window frames the best view of the bay! The upper level primary en suite has a storybook feel with built-ins, secluded loft with desk, refreshed, full bath and generously sized closet. The lower level family room offers the perfect respite from lazy summer days. Two spacious bedrooms, complete laundry center (flex space-kitchenette) & gorgeous remodeled full bath. Convenient mudroom with access to the backyard. This property is breathtaking with glorious views from every direction. Two out buildings allow space for storage and a potting shed with sink-perfect for the master gardener! Picket fence adds charm to this unique outdoor setting. A 2 car garage w/ breezeway to the house completes this perfect retreat.

470 S Donnybrook Road, Suttons Bay

$70,000

1943950 MLS ⋅ The Orchards BLDG.

Embrace the quiet beauty of Leelanau County with this pristine 2-acre lot on Blossom Lane. Tucked away in a peaceful country setting yet just minutes from the sparkling waters of Grand Traverse Bay, this property is Pure Up North Living. Imagine waking up to the gentle rustle of trees and the fresh lake air, with over two acres of level-to-rolling land providing ample space for your custom home and gardens. You are perfectly positioned just 2 miles from the Suttons Bay—where you can spend your mornings at the beach, your afternoons browsing local boutiques and your evenings at world-class wineries like Black Star Farms or Hop Lot Brewing. With Traverse City only 15 miles south, you get the rare combination of secluded calm and modern convenience. Bring your plans and start living the Up North dream.

11936 E Blossom Lane, Suttons Bay

$925,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1943530 MLS ⋅ Twin Maples Farms BLDG.

Set on 5.19 private acres in the heart of Leelanau County, this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers the perfect blend of comfort, space, and lifestyle. Surrounded by a peaceful blend of mature deciduous trees and rolling countryside, this property provides both privacy and convenience just north of Suttons Bay. The main level features well-defined living spaces that provide both comfort and functionality, with maple hardwood floors throughout the kitchen, living, and dining areas. The spacious kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, complete with granite countertops, newer appliances, and a large center island. A library or office on the main floor offers a quiet and functional work-from-home space, while the remodeled laundry room includes built-in beverage refrigerators for added convenience. Multiple living areas—including a cozy fireplace living room and a finished lower level with home theater and recreation space—offer flexibility for socializing, relaxing, reading, crafting, or movie nights. The main floor primary suite serves as a private retreat with a soaking tub, double-head tile shower, and two walk-in closets, and also offers direct access to the hot tub room, creating a true spa-like experience. The dedicated hot tub room provides year-round relaxation.This home has been thoughtfully updated with newer appliances, a newer roof (approximately 3 years), and numerous improvements throughout, along with the added benefit of a whole-home generator for peace of mind. Outdoor features include beautifully landscaped grounds, garden areas, and a fenced vegetable garden with raised beds, creating an ideal setting to enjoy Northern Michigan living. A rare opportunity to own a spacious, amenity-rich home on acreage in a highly desirable Leelanau location, offering privacy, versatility, and room to live, relax, and entertain. Furnishings and equipment for the movie room are included in the sale.

2567 N Evergreen Valley Drive, Suttons Bay

$81,000

1943351 MLS ⋅ Baycape Hills BLDG.

Set within a thoughtfully designed development, this exceptional 2.67-acre parcel offers the perfect blend of space, privacy, and scenic beauty. Gently rolling terrain and expansive countryside views create an ideal backdrop for your future home, where you can enjoy peaceful surroundings and breathtaking sunsets year-round. With ample room to build, this property provides flexibility for a variety of home styles, outdoor living spaces, and additional amenities. Located in a well-maintained community, you’ll appreciate the balance of rural charm and convenient access to nearby towns, shopping, and recreation. Whether you're envisioning a primary residence or a tranquil retreat, this picturesque setting is ready to bring your vision to life.

E John Michael Drive, Suttons Bay

$740,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1942990 MLS ⋅ Woodside Hills BLDG.

Perfectly located between Traverse City and Suttons Bay, this home is tucked into 2 heavily wooded acres, with an additional 1-acre parcel included. The extra privacy acts as a natural buffer and gives you a sense of incredible privacy. This neighborhood is surrounded by rolling hills in a desirable neighborhood. The layout of this home will work for a growing family or a down-sizer with a sizable main floor master with plenty of storage. Beautiful wood flooring, a vaulted ceiling in the living room and a very sizable lower level family room/entertainment area. This is a great home with lots of options to make it your own.

9871 E Woodcrest Court Unit 20 & 21, Suttons Bay

$3,600,000

1942870 MLS ⋅ Shady Lane Cellars BLDG.

Nestled amidst the scenic splendor of the Leelanau Peninsula in Northern Michigan, Shady Lane Cellars stands as a beacon of artisanal wine making and natural beauty. Includes 171.57 acres between 4 properties, 70 acres of vines, a first class winery, charming tasting room and several other building including a classic home. This winery has won numerous award for its wines and continues to innovate with new cultivars and estate bottled wines. This opportunity is turn-key and fully staffed.

9580 E Shady Lane, Suttons Bay

$197,000

1942837 MLS ⋅ Belanger Creek BLDG.

Belanger Creek – Lot 7. This private, quiet parcel offers a tranquil creekside building site with Belanger Creek flowing along the rear of the lot. Situated just 3 miles from the Village of Suttons Bay, it’s tucked at the end of a paved cul-de-sac and offers underground utilities, including natural gas and high-speed cable internet. Residents enjoy 8.5 acres of common open space, 2,100 feet of creek frontage, shared pond frontage, and building restrictions that maintain high-quality construction. Outbuildings are allowed on this parcel. Adjacent parcels are also available to purchase.

2171 N Belanger Creek Drive, Suttons Bay

$735,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1942720 MLS ⋅ The Orchards BLDG.

Exceptionally crafted 5 bd 4 bath home just south of Suttons Bay on the beautiful peninsula of Stony Pointe is awaiting it's next family! The main level features a large chef's kitchen opening to the living room anchored by a custom crafted 2 story stone fireplace framed by floor to ceiling windows. 5 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, with 2 den/office spaces leaves plenty of room for families to grow or to entertain guests. Upper level features a sprawling catwalk to the primary bedroom, a true oasis in and of itself with a custom tiled shower and heated floors throughout. The lower level walks out to the property with a separate entrance and features an oversized wet bar with granite countertops, a bedroom and bathroom with a dual vanity and a dedicated 2nd laundry room that connects to the garage. Additionally the property features a 30x40 detached pole barn with second level storage for all of your vehicle and miscellaneous storage needs. The home sits on a well maintained 2 acre parcel with mature landscaping, invisible pet fencing, underground sprinkler system, covered front porch, and large porch out the back. The Orchards subdivision has county maintained roads with low association fees for a low maintenance lifestyle. Just 4 minutes from Suttons Bay you truly have all of the best parts of the Leelanau lifestyle at your fingertips. From world class restaurants, to pristine sandy beaches, well awarded wineries, to the T.A.R.T bike trail connecting through Traverse City, this home truly has it all.

1474 S Montmorency Lane, Suttons Bay

$699,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1942613 MLS ⋅ Metes And Bounds BLDG.

Discover your own slice of Up North living just minutes from Suttons Bay. Built in 2018, this high-end 3-bedroom, 3-bath home features a full open floor plan, lofty ceilings, and abundant natural light. Set on over 5 acres of rolling hardwoods, the property offers privacy, room to roam, and—most importantly—future potential. With enough space for at least one additional buildable lot, or even the possibility of creating two separate lots or a duplex site, this setting presents a rare opportunity for both homeowners and investors alike. The home itself includes a walk-out lower level with a fully finished basement, adding flexible living space for entertaining, guests, or a home office. Inside, you’ll also find a spacious master suite and modern finishes throughout. Whether you’re looking for a year-round residence, a peaceful getaway, or a property with development options, this unique offering combines seclusion with accessibility to all the charm of Leelanau County.

4360 Independence Drive, Suttons Bay

$90,000

1942556 MLS

Bring your vision to life on a parcel that blends nature with development groundwork already in place. Located just outside the Village of Suttons Bay, this diverse property is positioned in one of Leelanau County’s most desirable areas. The landscape is richly layered with evergreens, select hardwoods, and native vegetation. In many areas, the growth is thick and natural, complemented by rolling terrain that carries you through a setting that feels untouched and distinctly Northern Michigan. Wetlands weave through portions of the property, inviting wildlife and enhancing privacy, while Leo Creek flows through the parcel, further contributing to its peaceful, natural character. The Leelanau Trail — part of the TART trail—runs along the eastern edge of the property, offering direct proximity to one of the region’s most beloved recreational corridors. Rather than a cleared, open lot, this parcel presents a unique opportunity for the next owner to shape the landscape with intention. A higher upland area rises above the surrounding terrain, offering a potential elevated homesite tucked within the trees. Sheltered and private, this setting provides the opportunity to transform natural elevation into your own vision. Significant groundwork has already been completed. A survey and wetland delineation have been finalized and proposed driveway location has been approved by the Road Commission. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy (EGLE) has reviewed the site and issued a permit for development. A perc test is scheduled for completion this spring to determine suitability for a septic system. The foundational steps are already in motion. Whether you envision a private Up North residence, a secluded recreational retreat, or a long-term investment just minutes from Suttons Bay’s marina, beaches, dining, and wineries, this property offers preparation, flexibility, and potential. Land like this doesn't simply offer space–it offers possibility.

00 S Center Highway, Suttons Bay

$74,000

1941786 MLS ⋅ The Orchards BLDG.

Set on 2.02 acres in The Orchards on Stony Point Peninsula, this high ground parcel offers an exceptional opportunity just north of Suttons Bay. Each lot in the neighborhood is thoughtfully designated at approximately two acres, creating space, privacy, and a cohesive feel throughout the community. The groundwork is already in place with underground electric, natural gas, cable internet, phone service, and a well installed and approved by the health department (buyer to install pump). Septic approval is in place, allowing you to move forward with confidence. From the property, enjoy a beautiful open meadow view, complemented by scattered shade trees and frequent wildlife, an ideal setting for a thoughtfully designed home. Reasonable restrictions are in place to ensure quality construction and protect long-term value. A rare combination of location and infrastructure.

1501 S Montmorency Lane, Suttons Bay

$2,999,900

11 Baths ⋅ 1941723 MLS ⋅ West Bay Shore Village BLDG.

One-of-a-kind fully leased commercial and residential building featuring a beautifully built restaurant, multiple wine tasting rooms, retail and office spaces, and four successful Airbnb rentals with a fifth coming soon, totaling over 18,000 square feet. The property includes a full bar with a Class C liquor license, commercial kitchen, food and beverage store/market, and indoor and outdoor seating for up to 300 guests, along with space for an on-site brewery and event barn. No additional licensing is required for a full brewpub operation with beer and wine takeout. Set on 4.3 acres with extensive frontage on highly traveled M-22, the property sits directly across from West Grand Traverse Bay, a public waterfront park, and boat launch. Beautiful bay views can be enjoyed throughout the property, including from the covered, three-season 1,700+ square foot wraparound porch. The existing building has been thoughtfully restored while still offering strong value-add potential, including a possible barn event space and two development parcels on the south side of the property—ideal for a brewery production building or additional residences. Ample parking, covered outdoor seating, and meticulous landscaping complete this exceptional setting. Seller financing or lease-to-own options available

5046 S West Bay Shore, Suttons Bay

$199,000

1941494 MLS ⋅ West Bay Shore Village BLDG.

Prime M-22 vacant land with exceptional visibility and strong traffic counts. High-exposure development site across from West Grand Traverse Bay, ideal for commercial or mixed-use projects (subject to zoning). Rare opportunity in a premier Northern Michigan corridor with long-term upside.

5046 S West Bay Shore Drive, Suttons Bay

$199,000

1941497 MLS ⋅ West Bay Shore Village BLDG.

Prime M-22 vacant land with exceptional visibility and strong traffic counts. High-exposure development site across from West Grand Traverse Bay, ideal for commercial or mixed-use projects (subject to zoning). Rare opportunity in a premier Northern Michigan corridor with long-term upside.

5046 S West Bay Shore Drive Unit 5, Suttons Bay

$199,000

1941498 MLS ⋅ West Bay Shore Village BLDG.

Prime M-22 vacant land with exceptional visibility and strong traffic counts. High-exposure development site across from West Grand Traverse Bay, ideal for commercial or mixed-use projects (subject to zoning). Rare opportunity in a premier Northern Michigan corridor with long-term upside.

5046 S West Bay Shore Drive Unit 6, Suttons Bay

$1,400,000

1941496 MLS ⋅ West Bay Shore Village BLDG.

Prime commercial space along M-22 with exceptional visibility and strong traffic counts. This turnkey 7,252 sq. ft. main-level space (Units 3 & 4) features a full commercial kitchen, bar, and spacious dining areas with indoor and outdoor seating. Lease rate is $15/sq. ft. “all in” (includes taxes, insurance, and CAM). Optional purchase of existing tables/chairs package and a transferable Class C liquor license with owner buyback option after lease term. Property includes ample parking, shared common areas, and attractive landscaping directly across from West Grand Traverse Bay. Additional Residential Units: • 1BR/1BA upper-level apartment, approx. 600 sq. ft. • 2BR/2BA two-story unit, approx. 850 sq. ft. Ideal for restaurant, tasting room, retail, or mixed-use operations seeking a high-exposure northern Michigan location.

5046 S West Bay Shore Unit 3 & 4, Suttons Bay

$199,000

1941493 MLS ⋅ West Bay Shore Village BLDG.

Prime M-22 vacant land with exceptional visibility and strong traffic counts. High-exposure development site across from West Grand Traverse Bay, ideal for commercial or mixed-use projects (subject to zoning). Rare opportunity in a premier Northern Michigan corridor with long-term upside.

5046 S West Bay Shore Drive, Suttons Bay

$975,000

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1940987 MLS

Incredible 29-Acre Opportunity on the Edge of Suttons Bay awaits. Discover one of the most versatile properties in Leelanau County—29 acres with an early-1900s farmhouse, two historic barns, and four additional outbuildings offering over 6,000 sq. ft. of total space and previously tilled fields. The farmhouse is a true fixer-upper with plenty of room for expansion, making it ideal for those looking to restore, renovate, or build a larger estate residence. With frontage on both a state highway and a secondary road where the property adjoins the Village of Suttons Bay limits, the location offers exceptional access and flexibility for future development. Less than a mile from downtown Suttons Bay and the shores of Lake Michigan, and only 30 minutes to Traverse City or Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore, this setting is surrounded by wineries, orchards, and the unmatched beauty of the Leelanau Peninsula. This parcel is part of a larger 150-acre farm also available for purchase. Lot splits are pending and sellers are open to making adjustments to parcel sizes. Whether you envision a private estate, agricultural use, or a thoughtful development project, the possibilities are endless. Property splits available.

9224 E Duck Lake Road Unit Parcel A, Suttons Bay

$4,925,000

1940809 MLS

Exceptional large acreage parcel with panoramic water views and unlimited potential just under a mile from Grand Traverse Bay and downtown Suttons Bay. Less than 30 minutes from Traverse City and within view of Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore. Approximately two-thirds of the acreage offers spectacular views of Grand Traverse Bay, with the highest elevations capturing vistas of Lake Leelanau, Lake Michigan, the Manitou Islands, and Pyramid Point. Property includes a farmhouse with attached garage, two early-1900s wood barns, a double pole barn, additional out buildings and three wells. Ideal for development of water-view homes, a luxury RV resort, winery, equestrian facility, or a private estate. Property touches the Village of Suttons Bay on the southeast corner along Smyseth Road. Owners are open to selling the property as three separate parcels of various sizes See the proposed splits in documents. Marketing packet with zoning details and conceptual development plans available upon request.

9224 E Duck Lake Road, Suttons Bay

$2,600,000

1940646 MLS

Introducing one of the most breathtaking development opportunities in Leelanau County—72 acres of high-elevation farmland carved from a historic 150-acre estate. This extraordinary parcel features some of the highest ridge lines in the county, delivering sweeping, multi-directional views rarely available on the market. Approximately two-thirds of the property offers water views, with vantage points that showcase the region’s most iconic landscapes. From the upper elevations, enjoy expansive views of Grand Traverse Bay, Suttons Bay, and Old Mission Peninsula to the east, while the western ridges capture unforgettable sunset views over Lake Michigan, Lake Leelanau, the Manitou Islands, and Pyramid Point, part of the Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore. Just under a mile from Grand Traverse Bay and downtown Suttons Bay—and less than 30 minutes from Traverse City—this parcel combines unmatched scenery with convenient access to the region’s restaurants, marinas, and recreation. Endless possibilities await: • Luxury estate homes with world-class views • A private ridge-top compound with sunrise and sunset vistas • An exclusive RV resort, retreat center, or equestrian property • A destination development leveraging the property’s dramatic topography Sellers are open to adjusting lot lines to accommodate buyer needs, and the full 149-acre farm is also available for those seeking a larger vision. Opportunities of this scale, beauty, and elevation in Leelanau County are exceedingly rare—this 72-acre ridge-top parcel is truly one-of-a-kind.

Parcel C E Duck Lake Road, Suttons Bay

$1,350,000

1940645 MLS

Discover the centerpiece of a 150-acre farm now being offered as three expansive parcels—this remarkable 46.5-acre tract of rolling farmland with water views presents unmatched potential in one of Leelanau County’s most desirable locations. Perfectly poised just under one mile from Grand Traverse Bay and downtown Suttons Bay, and less than 30 minutes from Traverse City, this property delivers the ideal blend of privacy, natural beauty, and convenience. Gently elevated terrain provides beautiful water views of the Bay, while open, usable acreage makes your vision achievable. The possibilities are truly unlimited. Create: • Water-view estate homes or a luxury residential community • A boutique winery or vineyard estate • A luxury RV resort or glamping retreat • An equestrian facility with room for pastures and riding trails • A private compound with space to spread out and grow The sellers are open to adjusting lot lines to fit buyer needs, providing additional flexibility for your desired use. The full 149-acre property is also available, offering even larger-scale potential. Whether you are a developer, investor, or someone seeking a legacy property, this parcel stands out as a rare and extraordinary offering in Suttons Bay.

Parcel B E Duck Lake Road, Suttons Bay

$699,000

1940578 MLS ⋅ West Bay Shore Village BLDG.

Discover an exceptional opportunity in the heart of Leelanau County — Unit #2 of this landmark mixed-use property combines three beautifully finished wine tasting rooms, multiple restrooms, and a small commercial kitchen designed for boutique food and beverage operations. The space blends character and functionality, offering an ideal setting for wine tasting, private events, or specialty retail. Adding to its appeal, the unit also includes a one-bedroom apartment that operates as a successful, ADA-compliant short-term rental, providing both additional income and flexibility for an on-site manager or owner. Located along scenic M-22 with high visibility and steady traffic, this property sits across from West Grand Traverse Bay and a popular public waterfront park and boat launch. Guests and visitors enjoy convenient access, ample parking, and a setting that captures the essence of Northern Michigan’s wine country charm. This unique combination of commercial and residential space presents a turnkey opportunity to own and operate within one of the region’s most desirable corridors — a rare blend of lifestyle and investment potential.

5046 S West Bay Shore Unit 2, Suttons Bay

$2,700

1940577 MLS ⋅ West Bay Shore Village BLDG.

Now available for lease along scenic M-22! Unit #2 offers three beautifully finished wine tasting rooms, multiple restrooms, and a small commercial kitchen — an ideal setup for a boutique tasting room, café, or specialty retail use. Situated directly across from West Grand Traverse Bay and a popular public waterfront park, this property provides excellent visibility, ample parking, and a stunning Northern Michigan setting. A rare opportunity to establish your business in one of the region’s most desirable corridors! Lease to own options available!

5046 S West Bay Shore, Suttons Bay

$1,235,000

1940390 MLS ⋅ Metes And Bounds BLDG.

76 ACRE OMENA PARCEL, BAY VIEWS, ACTIVE ORCHARD, ASSURED PRIVACY. This is a chance you won't get again. Acquire a premium agricultural parcel in the rolling high country above Omena, featuring beautiful Grand Traverse Bay views from multiple locations. This 76-acre parcel maintains Leelanau's farming culture and offers the potential continuation of the agricultural tax exemption. The farm includes about 25 acres of producing orchard: 17 acres of Montmorency tart cherries and 7.7 acres of Empire/Supermac apples. 15 acres are ripe for expansion. A local grower professionally maintains the orchard, ensuring agricultural continuity for inexperienced owners. Value and privacy are assured: The property adjoins the Leelanau Conservancy’s 84-acre protected parcel to the east, ensuring your neighboring landscape remains permanently unspoiled and development-free. A diverse landscape awaits, including acres of open fields, mature woods sloping to a creek, and an existing 6-inch well. The ideal setting for a private agricultural estate.

11965 E Freeland Road, Suttons Bay

$9,000

1940322 MLS ⋅ West Bay Shore Village BLDG.

Prime restaurant, tasting room, or retail space available for lease along M-22 with high visibility and strong traffic counts. Offering 7,252 sq. ft. on the main level of Units 3 and 4, this turnkey space includes a full commercial kitchen, bar, and dining areas with indoor and outdoor seating. Lease rate of $15/sq. ft. “all in” includes taxes, insurance, and CAM. Optional purchase of existing tables/chairs package and transferable Class C liquor license with owner buyback option after the lease. Ample parking, shared common areas, and beautiful landscaping add to this outstanding location across from West Grand Traverse Bay. Lease to own options available!

5046 S West Bay Shore Unit Main floor of 3 & 4, Suttons Bay

$899,900

1940321 MLS ⋅ West Bay Shore Village BLDG.

Beautifully finished group of condo spaces offering modern comfort in a one-of-a-kind mixed-use building across from West Grand Traverse Bay. Rent with purchase option available! There are currently two units that can be short term rented on the main floor, with an upstairs office space that has had a very solid tenant for more than 20 years. This well-maintained building unit features quality finishes, abundant natural light, and spacious layouts ideal for full-time living or short-term rental use. Enjoy access to the property’s covered wrap-around porch with partial bay views, ample parking, and landscaped grounds. Located on highly traveled M-22, directly across from a public park and boat launch, this location provides convenient access to downtown Traverse City and surrounding wineries, beaches, and attractions.

5046 S West Bay Shore Unit 1, Suttons Bay

$4,925,000

1940220 MLS

Discover one of Leelanau County’s most spectacular development opportunities — nearly 150 acres of rolling countryside with panoramic water views in every direction. Just under a mile from Grand Traverse Bay and downtown Suttons Bay, and less than 30 minutes from Traverse City, this rare property offers the perfect balance of serenity and accessibility. From its highest elevations, take in sweeping vistas of Lake Michigan, Lake Leelanau, the Manitou Islands, Pyramid Point, and Grand Traverse Bay—a truly breathtaking canvas for a visionary developer, investor, or estate builder. The property includes two early-1900s barns, plus additional farm buildings and the original farmhouse that can be retained, restored, or separated as desired. Unlimited potential awaits—envision water-view estates, a luxury RV resort, boutique winery, equestrian retreat, or an exclusive private compound. A marketing packet with zoning details and conceptual development plans is available upon request. The Village of Suttons Bay touches the property’s southeast corner, opening the possibility of additional utility connections. The owners will consider dividing the property into three parcels. A conceptual site plan is attached in documents.

9224 E Duck Lake Road, Suttons Bay

$70,000

1940071 MLS ⋅ The Orchards BLDG.

Stony Point Peninsula, 29 estate-sized lots.Private well already drilled. Nestled in a quiet scenic setting with underground utilities and the convenience of being just a short bike ride to the village of Suttons Bay for fine dining, shopping and everyday essentials. Build your dream home in one of the area's most desirable locations where open space meets small town charm.

11954 E Blossom Lane, Suttons Bay

$553,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1939485 MLS ⋅ Metes & Bounds BLDG.

Take in all that Pure Leelanau County has to offer in this country oasis. Beautiful 1 story home situated on 6.8 acres. Point of sale on file. Home has 2 bathrooms and in addition to the two baths in home, out building has a bathroom. Home takes advantage of the natural surroundings, featuring a bright semi open concept floor plan. Spacious front patio with pergola & large rear deck. Hardwood flooring flows through main floor living areas. Dining area with large slider lets in nice country side views. Main floor primary with walk in closet and 2 way fireplace. Full walk-out lower level with finished family room. Additional second garage features 29'x29' garage bay and additional finished space. Enjoy all the peacefulness & tranquility found in this great setting yet only short drive to downtown Sutton’s Bay and all the beauty of Leelanau County.

9750 E Solem Road, Suttons Bay

$835,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1939476 MLS ⋅ Twin Maple Farm BLDG.

Peaceful Country Living in the Heart of Leelanau County! Tucked away on 2.47 acres of rolling countryside, this stunning 4-bedroom, 4-bath home offers over 3,500 sq. ft. of beautifully finished living space in one of Leelanau County’s most desirable locations. Just five minutes from the vibrant Village of Suttons Bay, you’ll enjoy the perfect blend of tranquility and convenience—close to local shops, wineries, restaurants, and Lake Michigan beaches. Built with quality and style in mind, this home welcomes you with an open floor plan, soaring ceilings, and a wall of windows that frames peaceful countryside views. The gourmet kitchen features granite countertops, an island, and stainless steel appliances, flowing seamlessly into the great room with a cozy wood-burning fireplace. With luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout, daylight windows in the lower level, and an attached 3-stall garage, every detail has been thoughtfully designed. Enjoy morning coffee or evening sunsets on the covered porch overlooking the scenic property. Whether you’re looking for a year-round home, vacation getaway, or an ideal short-term rental investment (Airbnb), this property delivers on lifestyle and opportunity. Experience the best of Leelanau living—peaceful surroundings, endless recreation, and easy access to the charm of Suttons Bay, Leland, Northport, and Traverse City—all within minutes.

2528 N Setterbo Road, Suttons Bay

$1,500,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 1939279 MLS ⋅ Nabawnaga Shores No. 4 BLDG.

Enjoy breathtaking, 180-degree Bay views over Old Mission Peninsula and beyond from this beautifully designed 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath ranch home. With over 3,600 finished square feet, this home offers generous living spaces, soaring 17-foot cathedral ceilings, and expansive windows that flood the interior with natural light and frame the stunning Bay vistas. The open-concept layout includes spacious living room and family room, each with a cozy fireplace, perfect for entertaining or relaxing. The main level also features a dedicated den or home office, formal and informal dining areas, and two bedroom suites. The owner was in process of remodeling the kitchen and it is a blank slate, ready for buyer to add their own design & style. Bathrooms boast ceramic tile, vanities with granite countertops. Hardwood flooring flows throughout the main level, while the full walkout lower level includes in-floor radiant heat for year-round comfort. Additional highlights include 8-zone heating system, central air conditioning, a wooded, elevated lot offering privacy and natural beauty, built-in gazebo and waterside deck, shared West Bay water access just a short walk away. This exceptional home seamlessly combines comfort and unmatched Bay views, an ideal Northern Michigan retreat or year-round residence. Highest & best offers due Monday, October 6, 2025 at 5:00pm.

931 S Ridgeview Trail, Suttons Bay

$729,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1939236 MLS ⋅ Brigadoon Estates BLDG.

Discover this thoughtfully designed ranch estate set on more than five acres, offering endless agricultural potential and stunning views of rolling hills, vineyards, orchards, and seasonal glimpses of the bay. Located just two miles south of Suttons Bay, this rare property provides convenient main level living with timeless craftsmanship and inviting spaces. Hand-hewn hardwood floors set the tone for the open-concept granite kitchen, dining, and living areas. A cozy family room with custom built-ins offers a perfect place to unwind, while the generous primary suite extends into a private three-season room that leads to an expansive patio with a custom pergola and built-in seating—creating an exceptional outdoor living space. Additional conveniences include a solid-surface laundry area with abundant cabinetry, half bath, and direct garage access. The finished walk-out lower level adds incredible flexibility, with 9-foot ceilings, its own entrance, a quartz kitchen, living room, full bath, and two bedrooms. Complete with an outdoor entertaining area and raised fire pit, it’s ideal for guests, in-laws, or multi-generational living. Designed with durability in mind, this home offers a long list of features: screened front porch, custom 3" wood entry doors with leaded-glass interior details, 20x24 pole barn with water and electricity, cedar shake garden shed, full-house generator, underground electric, fenced backyard, raised garden beds, lavender field, irrigation system, James Hardie siding, and more. Follow the private, winding road through this peaceful neighborhood to your Northern Michigan dream retreat. Some images have been virtually staged. Third bedroom is nonconforming.

11300 E Brigadoon Lane, Suttons Bay

$3,200,000

1939094 MLS ⋅ Ciccone Vineyard & Winery BLDG.

Build your legacy in Leelanau County with this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. Ciccone Vineyard and Winery is a sprawling estate with a strong brand in an ideal location, and an incredibly picturesque property with unobstructed views of Grand Traverse Bay from many vantage points. This trophy opportunity is completely turn-key with a successful wine and event business, as well as a Winemaker's home or bed and breakfast accommodations. Ciccone's award-winning wines are made exclusively from estate-grown grapes - produced and bottled on-site. Ciccone has a superb staff, a huge and growing wine club following, and the historic barn and event spaces are well-booked throughout the year. Built in 1990, the two story Winemaker's home has gorgeous views in all directions - with 5 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, a large open main-level floor plan, immaculate grounds, and lots of outdoor entertainment spaces, the home has multiple potential uses including bed and breakfast, event guest space, and more. The kitchen has many updates including newer cabinets and counters, and the living areas all point to the views of the bay or the adjacent sprawling vineyard. The home is freshly painted, and has adequate storage areas as well as an attached three car garage. The Winemaker's home is also on its own 2 acre lot, which could be beneficial for flexible uses - or, it's a lovely primary home and perfectly positioned to oversee the entire Ciccone operation. In addition to the existing operation and lovely home, there is expansion potential as well. Plans for an onsite café, new production building, expanded vineyard potential, and event pavilion are all in hand and can be shared with the next steward of the property. The property consists of multiple parcels, which could be a flexible benefit as well. Sip award-winning wine from the back patio or the historic barn, overlooking sprawling vineyards, and a bay of blue. This Leelanau experience is definitely one to see in order to appreciate!

10343 E Hilltop Road, Suttons Bay

View All Latest Suttons Bay 2+ Acre Properties for Sale

2+ Acres Suttons Bay Real Estate