Browse All Suttons Bay MI Between $200K - $300K Properties for Sale

1946069 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.

This gently sloping 10-acre parcel has panoramic views of rolling hills and orchards. Centrally located in Leelanau County—just four miles to Suttons Bay and Lake Leelanau, and under 10 miles to Leland—this location on Maple Valley Road gives you so many options for shopping or dining. This property is the perfect size for your “gentleman’s estate.” No deed restrictions. Bring your mini donkeys!

00 Maple Valley Road, Suttons Bay

$265,000

1944175 MLS ⋅ The Points BLDG.

WATER VIEWS! A rare opportunity to own 2.8 acres in "The Points at Suttons Bay", where open space and elevated positioning combine to showcase beautiful views of Grand Traverse Bay and the countryside. The size of this parcel allows for a truly custom build—whether you envision a modern retreat or a timeless Northern Michigan home—with room to create privacy while still being part of a well-established neighborhood. Minutes to Suttons Bay, yet offering a peaceful, tucked-away feel. Sellers have recently combined parcels 3 & 4 to create this spectacular Estate Size parcel. New survey shows the combined parcels and a substantial foot-print for a proposed and approved home plan. See all associated documents. All listing data has been obtained from seller or third party sources and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Buyer, or its agent should verify all for accuracy. Tax ID's 011-600-003-00 & 004-00.

E Spinnaker Lane, Suttons Bay

$266,000

1938241 MLS ⋅ N/A BLDG.

If you've been searching for the perfect Leelanau County vacant parcel, one that offers hardwoods, conifers, some open land, both level and rolling topography, with exceptional privacy, your quest may be over! This spectacular 10 acre parcel is located just a couple miles south of the quaint village of Suttons Bay in northwest Bingham Township. A gravel driveway guides you halfway through this parcel, where there are several very attractive sites to build your up north get away. Stately hardwoods, mature pines, open meadow with wild grape vines and mulberry trees, are all a part of the landscape. Quiet Erdt Road, certainly not a thru route, is the destination point, where you'll enjoy the countryside perspectives of the rolling farm fields, forests, and vineyards. Veronica Valley Park, converted from a former golf course is a nice hike or bike ride away, you can also gain access to the popular Leelanau Trail and ride from Traverse City to Suttons Bay. Bring your builder and architect to explore the numerous building sites, depending on what you want your perspective to be, in the woods, the open meadow, or a little of both!

Erdt Road, Suttons Bay

$299,000

1938095 MLS ⋅ Metes & Bounds BLDG.

This is your chance to own 1.29 acres of prime land with 120 feet of private frontage on the clear, coveted waters of West Bay. Set along a quiet stretch just minutes from downtown Traverse City, the property offers the ideal setting for a luxury new build - spacious, scenic, and surrounded by natural beauty. With level topography and expansive views, the site is perfectly suited for a custom home designed to take full advantage of the waterfront lifestyle. Think morning paddle sessions, evening bonfires by the bay, and unforgettable sunsets from your own backyard. Whether you’re creating a private getaway or a legacy home, this rare slice of shoreline is ready for what’s next.

5382 S West Bay Shore, Suttons Bay

$265,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1937271 MLS ⋅ Murray Farm BLDG.

Tucked away at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, this 4 bed/2 bath ranch in Suttons Bay is full of potential for the right buyer. Features include an attached 2-car garage, spacious deck, a sun porch off the primary bedroom, and a large backyard that’s ready for gardening, gathering, or both. The unfinished basement adds even more opportunity, whether you're thinking storage, workshop, or future finished space. It does need some work and is being sold As Is, but the location is a win: just minutes to the shops and restaurants in the Village of Suttons Bay, and a quick drive to Traverse City. If you're looking for a project with upside in Leelanau County, this might be the one.

10775 E Murray Court, Suttons Bay

$211,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1936463 MLS ⋅ Murray Farm Subdivision BLDG.

Charming Ranch Home in Ideal Suttons Bay Location! Easy one-floor living in this well-maintained 3 bed/2 bath ranch-style home, nestled on over half an acre in a peaceful Suttons Bay subdivision. This property offers the perfect balance of privacy and convenience, located just minutes from the vibrant communities of Suttons Bay, Traverse City, and Leland. Step inside to a bright, open layout designed for comfort and functionality. The home flows seamlessly to a spacious outdoor deck, ideal for summer entertaining, morning coffee, or evening gatherings under the stars. The beautifully landscaped yard offers room to garden, play, or simply relax in your own Up North retreat. Outdoor enthusiasts will love being just 1.5 miles from the TART Trail, perfect for biking and walking adventures. Beaches, wineries, art galleries, and Leelanau County’s renowned natural beauty are all close by. Don’t miss this rare opportunity for comfortable, single-level living in one of Northern Michigan’s most desirable locations!

10892 E Murray Court, Suttons Bay

$200,000

1934297 MLS

20 Acres Adjacent to Herman Park & Surrounded by Protected Land This rare 20-acre parcel in Suttons Bay offers an exceptional opportunity for conservationists, hunters, or outdoor enthusiasts looking to own land in one of Leelanau County’s most protected and scenic corridors. Directly bordering Herman Park—a 126-acre community hub with trails, courts, fields, and family-friendly amenities—this wooded, wetland-rich property provides outstanding wildlife habitat and is especially ideal for deer hunting. To the east, it adjoins nearly 95 acres of public land owned by Suttons Bay Township and the Village of Suttons Bay. To the southeast, it neighbors 67 acres permanently preserved by the Leelanau Conservancy. Also nearby is the Leelanau Trail, a paved multi-use trail connecting Suttons Bay to Traverse City, perfect for biking, walking, and enjoying the region’s natural beauty. With protected land on multiple sides and easy access to both nature and community resources, this parcel is perfect for those who want to leave a lasting impact—or simply enjoy their own private slice of Leelanau County. A rare opportunity to own land that connects people, parks, and preservation. This property is located within a wetland, according to the EGLE's Wetland Inventory Map, but that doesn't necessarily mean that no development is possible--"only an onsite evaluation performed by EGLE...shall be used for jurisdictional determinations." (Michigan EGLE)

S Center Highway, Suttons Bay

$260,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1928972 MLS ⋅ Peshawbestown BLDG.

Nestled in the heart of picturesque Leelanau County, this move-in ready 4-bedroom home offers comfort, functionality, and a welcoming open-concept design. The spacious kitchen, featuring ample counter space and a walk-in pantry, is thoughtfully located next to a convenient laundry room with easy access to the backyard. Bright and filled with natural light, the home offers two main living areas—one with a cozy gas fireplace and a slider leading to an outdoor deck, perfect for relaxation or gatherings. Outdoors, the large yard provides plenty of space for activities, complete with a fire pit for evening enjoyment. A 2-car carport protects your vehicles, while three additional outdoor sheds offer abundant storage for tools, lawn equipment, and recreational gear. This unique property sits on land owned by the Grand Traverse Band of Ottawa & Chippewa Indians. The sale includes the home only, with a 99-year land lease on the property for Grand Traverse Band members only. Don’t miss this exceptional opportunity for tribal members to own this charming, well-appointed home.

3319 N West Bay Shore Drive, Suttons Bay

$210,000

1922058 MLS ⋅ Village View BLDG.

Build your dream home with spectacular views, on the last available vacant lot in this Suttons Bay neighborhood! Village View is a small neighborhood of quality homes featuring a paved private road, natural gas, underground electric, and high speed cable internet.This elevated lot overlooks orchards, The Bay, and The Village! Minutes to downtown Suttons Bay, boat launches, public beaches, restaurants, wineries, and so much more. Building photos are ones that were HOA approved prior to seller moving out of the area.

760 S Village View Court, Suttons Bay

$200,000

1911504 MLS ⋅ Blue Water Ridge BLDG.

Now accepting offers on this beautiful one-acre gem with breathtaking views of Grand Traverse Bay. This development offers an incredible opportunity for buyers looking for a summer home. In the heart of the Leelanau Peninsula with its plethora of vineyards, hiking and biking trails, beaches, and parks, including Sleeping Bear Dune National Lakeshore, it is also just 2.5 miles from the charming town of Suttons Bay with its many amenities, marina, and beach. A must-see property for anyone dreaming of owning a luxury home near Lake Michigan in a setting that rivals Napa Valley. In addition to the stunning water views, the western edge of the property hugs a bucolic and sprawling cherry orchard that is deeded as agricultural land. Zoning regulations within the development specify that only 1-story structures can be built on the properties in front of the house so as to ensure water sight lines. Complete with 31 acres of common area, a private paved road, low association fees, underground electric, cable, high speed internet, and developer-built underground propane and drain field system routed to each individual home, it is the perfect spot to build the ideal Northern Michigan dream home! Sold separately are the drawings for a four-bedroom American Farmhouse design that includes a ground floor owner’s suite and an open plan LR, DR, KT. Photo realistic renderings supplement the completed contract documents for this site with the already completed cut & amp; fill and driveway access. The plans situate the house on the back of the lot to maximize unobstructed views of the water to the east and the cherry orchard to the west and to minimize the impact of other structures on the sight lines of the house. Enjoy your morning coffee watching the sun rise over the bay, and then sit by a campfire in your own garden in the evening to watch the sun set over the orchard.

1867 N Blue Water Court, Suttons Bay

$264,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1917218 MLS ⋅ York Condominiums BLDG.

Wonderful location! This 3 bedroom, 2 bath end unit York Condominium offers an open living room and kitchen/dining with hickory wood floors and newer appliances, main floor bedroom & main floor full bath, natural gas forced air heat with A/C, and a finished walk out lower level with laminate maintenance free flooring throughout, 2 bedrooms and a 2nd full bath! Shared amenities include an in-ground swimming pool, trails, tennis court, and a shared well & septic. Low maintenance living in a very convenient location just 10-15 minutes from Downtown Traverse City! Association fee ($300/month) covers exterior building maintenance, lawn care, snow removal, garbage, shared septic & well. This is an end unit in the D building (4th building from Fort Road) which offers a quiet location within the 44 acre complex. New shingles to be installed in 2024/2025, assessment of $6,000 will be paid in full by the Seller at the closing of the sale with an acceptable offer.

11255 E Fort Road Unit D-1, Suttons Bay

$265,000

1921374 MLS

This beautiful south facing is parcel consists of just over 6 acres. Stunning views can be had, from multiple suitable build sights, with minimal tree removal. The rolling sloping terrain makes this a perfect site for a home with a walk out basement. Come build your dream in the quiet serine surroundings that make this a true Leelanau county Gem.

S Maple Valley Road, Suttons Bay

$291,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1912082 MLS ⋅ Silver Leaf Farm Est BLDG.

2 Bedroom Ranch on a gorgeous 7.9 acres in Suttons Bay Township with fabulous trials that meander through mature hardwoods. Some fruit trees and approximately 20 mushroom spore species planted throughout property some of which are producing. Near Suttons Bay with grocery, public boat launch, schools, churches and parks. Sawmill could be included in sale.

11155 E Silver Leaf Farm Road, Suttons Bay

Start Your Search

Between $200K - $300K Suttons Bay Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $200k - $300k properties available in Suttons Bay and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!